Black Foils · fleet analysis

Takeoff technique and the upwind VMG angle

Two questions, one day of data. Takeoff turns out to be an unusually tight speed gate that the whole fleet meets within a couple of km/h — and the daggerboard rake is a trigger pulled at that speed, not a run-up to it. Upwind, there is a clear best angle, and almost nobody sailed it.

Takeoff speed
30.3
km/h (16.4 kt) · spread only 4.2%
Speed at full rake
30.0
km/h · 2.0 s before takeoff
Best upwind angle
50°
at 39.9 km/h → VMG 26.6
Fleet actually sailed
77°
USA median — 28° too wide

Takeoff is a speed gate, and everyone meets it

Across 49 takeoffs the median speed is 30.3 km/h (16.4 kt), and the spread between boats is almost nothing — NZL takes off at 29.8 and USA at 31.0. The coefficient of variation across every takeoff is 4.2%. Whatever else differs between these teams, the speed at which an F50 will fly does not.

282930313233fleet median 30.3NZL: takeoff 29.8 km/h (16.1 kt), n=13NZL29.8 km/h · 13 TOCAN: takeoff 29.9 km/h (16.1 kt), n=8CAN29.9 km/h · 8 TODEN: takeoff 30.3 km/h (16.4 kt), n=5DEN30.3 km/h · 5 TOAUS: takeoff 30.5 km/h (16.5 kt), n=7AUS30.5 km/h · 7 TOESP: takeoff 30.7 km/h (16.6 kt), n=9ESP30.7 km/h · 9 TOUSA: takeoff 31.0 km/h (16.7 kt), n=7USA31.0 km/h · 7 TOMedian takeoff speed (km/h)
Median takeoff speed by boat. The whole fleet sits inside a 1.2 km/h window.

The rake is a trigger, not a run-up

You asked for the speed at the moment the boat goes to maximum rake. That moment is later than it sounds: the median boat commits to full rake just 2.0 seconds before it flies, at 30.0 km/h — which is within half a km/h of the takeoff speed itself. The boats are not raking early and accelerating onto the foils; they reach flying speed and then pull the trigger.

80% of takeoffs peg the board at the mechanical stop (7.79°, which is the highest value any of these six boats records all day). So "how much rake" is not really a variable — it is full rake, nearly always. The variable is when.

BoatTakeoffsSpeed at full rakeSpeed at takeoffPeak rakeRake lead (s)TWS
NZL1329.329.87.82.513.2
CAN830.429.97.71.814.5
DEN530.330.37.83.014.9
AUS730.430.57.82.513.7
ESP929.930.77.71.514.6
USA731.131.07.81.515.6

The upwind angle: 50°, and the fleet sailed 28° wider

In the one wind band with enough data to answer the question — 12–16 km/h (6.5–8.6 kt) — VMG peaks at 50° TWA at 39.9 km/h boat speed, giving 26.6 km/h VMG (14.4 kt). That is a real peak rather than the edge of the data: 46° and 52° either side both give less (26.2 and 25.0).

05101520253045505560657075808590where the fleet actually sailedTWA 46 deg: VMG 26.25 km/h (14.17 kt), BSP 37.9, n=91TWA 50 deg: VMG 26.62 km/h (14.37 kt), BSP 39.9, n=98TWA 52 deg: VMG 25.00 km/h (13.50 kt), BSP 38.5, n=132TWA 56 deg: VMG 22.59 km/h (12.20 kt), BSP 38.2, n=198TWA 58 deg: VMG 21.02 km/h (11.35 kt), BSP 38.9, n=351TWA 62 deg: VMG 20.07 km/h (10.84 kt), BSP 40.7, n=321TWA 64 deg: VMG 17.60 km/h (9.50 kt), BSP 39.3, n=366TWA 68 deg: VMG 16.01 km/h (8.64 kt), BSP 38.8, n=297TWA 70 deg: VMG 13.33 km/h (7.20 kt), BSP 38.1, n=242TWA 74 deg: VMG 11.65 km/h (6.29 kt), BSP 37.9, n=279TWA 76 deg: VMG 8.93 km/h (4.82 kt), BSP 36.4, n=353TWA 80 deg: VMG 6.47 km/h (3.49 kt), BSP 35.4, n=294TWA 82 deg: VMG 4.58 km/h (2.47 kt), BSP 35.6, n=232TWA 86 deg: VMG 3.93 km/h (2.12 kt), BSP 34.4, n=195TWA 88 deg: VMG 2.07 km/h (1.12 kt), BSP 35.2, n=230best VMG 26.6 at 50°TWA (degrees)VMG (km/h)
Upwind VMG against TWA, 12–16 km/h TWS, all six boats pooled. Each point is the median of at least 30 samples. The shaded band is where the fleet actually spent its upwind time.

The gap is the finding. Every boat's median upwind angle was between 64° and 77°. The best-VMG angle is 50°. Only ESP and NZL spent even a sixth of their upwind time tighter than 55°.

45505560657075808590best VMG angle 50°DEN: median 64 deg, 10th-75th 56-75, VMG 18.14 km/hDEN64° med · VMG 18.1NZL: median 68 deg, 10th-75th 53-77, VMG 16.46 km/hNZL68° med · VMG 16.5ESP: median 66 deg, 10th-75th 49-76, VMG 15.33 km/hESP66° med · VMG 15.3CAN: median 68 deg, 10th-75th 59-79, VMG 13.07 km/hCAN68° med · VMG 13.1AUS: median 74 deg, 10th-75th 57-80, VMG 11.42 km/hAUS74° med · VMG 11.4USA: median 77 deg, 10th-75th 56-83, VMG 10.36 km/hUSA77° med · VMG 10.4TWA sailed (dot = median, bar = 10th-75th percentile)
Where each boat sailed upwind against the best-VMG angle. Dot is the median; the bar spans the 10th to 75th percentile.

Why footing off costs you

Normally you accept a wider angle because it buys speed. On this day it did not. Boat speed is essentially flat across the whole range — about 38–40 km/h from 46° all the way out to 70°, and it falls beyond that. With no speed to gain, widening the angle only costs the cosine, so VMG drops monotonically.

3035404545505560657075808590TWA 46: BSP 37.9 km/h (20.4 kt)TWA 50: BSP 39.9 km/h (21.5 kt)TWA 52: BSP 38.5 km/h (20.8 kt)TWA 56: BSP 38.2 km/h (20.6 kt)TWA 58: BSP 38.9 km/h (21.0 kt)TWA 62: BSP 40.7 km/h (22.0 kt)TWA 64: BSP 39.3 km/h (21.2 kt)TWA 68: BSP 38.8 km/h (21.0 kt)TWA 70: BSP 38.1 km/h (20.6 kt)TWA 74: BSP 37.9 km/h (20.4 kt)TWA 76: BSP 36.4 km/h (19.7 kt)TWA 80: BSP 35.4 km/h (19.1 kt)TWA 82: BSP 35.6 km/h (19.2 kt)TWA 86: BSP 34.4 km/h (18.6 kt)TWA 88: BSP 35.2 km/h (19.0 kt)TWA (degrees)Boat speed (km/h)
Boat speed against TWA over the same data. Flat, then declining — there is no speed reward for sailing wider.
BoatMinutes upwindMedian TWATime tighter than 55°BSP km/hVMG km/h
DEN3.4647.8%37.918.14
NZL5.66816.9%38.816.46
ESP8.76617.0%36.415.33
CAN5.0685.3%39.713.07
AUS5.1746.2%37.211.42
USA3.1778.5%36.410.36

Which wind bands could actually be answered

You asked for bands from 6 to 14. Two things get in the way. The speed channels are km/h, not knots, despite what the app's sliders say — and the upwind foiling data only spans 11.0 to 18.9 km/h (5.9–10.2 kt). Within that, only two bands have enough angular coverage to show a peak rather than an edge. The rest are reported honestly as unanswerable rather than given a number.

TWS km/hTWS ktSamplesBest TWABSP km/hVMG km/h
8–104.3–5.465———not enough data
10–125.4–6.55595239.324.8not bracketed
12–146.5–7.623995039.826.9optimum found
14–167.6–8.613185239.426.5optimum found
16–188.6–9.74355239.025.4not bracketed
18–209.7–10.8211———not enough data
20–2210.8–11.9105———not enough data

What I would take from this

Takeoff: there is little to coach in the speed — everyone hits 30 km/h. The question worth asking is whether committing rake earlier, while still accelerating, gets the boat up sooner. Right now the whole fleet does the same thing: reach flying speed, then rake.

Upwind: this is the actionable one. 50° at 40 km/h was worth 26.6 km/h of VMG; the fleet's habitual 77° was worth far less. Median angle tracks median VMG straight down the fleet: DEN sailed the tightest median (64°) and got the best VMG (18.1); USA sailed the widest (77°) and got the worst (10.4).

How much to trust this

Only 31.0 minutes of steady upwind foiling sits in the 12–16 km/h band across all six boats, and this was a training day, not racing — 42 of 49 takeoffs were into a reach. The upwind peak is well sampled at the angles the boats actually sailed, but the tight end (under 46°) rests on the thinnest data on the chart. Treat 50° as "tighter than you are sailing", not as a precise target.